MAINTAINING
CUSTOMER SERVICE STANDARDS
WHEN THE CASH IS LEAN
Many companies spend enormous amounts of time, money and energy to
acquire new customers. Yet how many of these companies spend the same time,
energy and money to maintain and grow their existing customer base? In today's
marketplace, where most companies are feverishly working to grow market share,
prospective users get the attention and deals while loyal customers sometimes
get left in the dust with little attention and less desirable offerings.
“PENNY- WISE & POUND-FOOLISH” APPROACH
The challenging economy is putting consumer companies such as airlines,
banks, and retailers in the difficult position of cutting back the service levels
that customers have come to expect in recent years. These companies are
closing retail locations, reducing hours of operation, and making do with less
staff in stores and call centers. Meanwhile, faced with rising costs, they are also increasing prices, either overtly or through fees. As a result, customer
experience research shows that satisfaction scores are reversing the upward trend of the past few years and actually dropping in a number of industries.
So it’s not surprising that most executives think compromising service levels is
a mistake.
How can consumer businesses make necessary investments in
service while facing the pressure on revenues and costs? Our review of the companies with
the best customer service records in ten industries suggests that one key is to
minimize wasteful spending while learning to invest in the drivers of
satisfaction. Specifically, companies should challenge their beliefs about service
and test those beliefs analytically. Many will discover that long-held but
seldom-reviewed assertions about what customers really want are wrong.
Consider service levels, specifically average time-to-answer,
which is one of the
most common metrics used in call centers. Service levels—often based on
regulation or historical precedent—are set by call-center managers and then
used to calculate staffing requirements. But service levels are challenging to
maintain and costly to improve: raising them by 10 percent requires much more than a 10 percent increase in staff.
You can see this happening today with cellular and phone service
providers. It seems that every week there is a new deal available to people whom
are willing to switch phone plans. Customer loyalty crumbles as customers chase
the next best deal. To counter a similar trend, one insurance brokerage firm
took bold action when they saw term life insurance rates decrease significantly
over recent years. They decided to contact every customer who had a term policy
with them and let those customers know that they could obtain more dollar
coverage or increased term length for the same monthly investment. Customers
were ecstatic. As a result, company insurance policy sales went up because the
goodwill that was demonstrated by the brokerage firm generated more business
for them from their current customer base.
HOW TO ENGINEER A SERVICE TURNAROUND
Why are service turnarounds so tough? One reason may be that the front line at
a service company is the product. A manufacturer's customers can't usually tell
when workers at its production plant are unhappy. At a service company, on the
other hand, any dip in morale is painfully obvious.
Another reason is that frontline staff control communication with customers.
One of their jobs is to keep customers informed when things go wrong. In the
mid-1980s, when Indian Airlines was experiencing service problems, one of us
was told by a gate agent, "If you didn't want your flight canceled, you
should have picked another airline" — hardly an inducement to repurchase.
By contrast, manufacturing companies can manage customer communication much
more directly through their head office and salesforce.
Since most management thinking about turnarounds is based on manufacturing
companies, the strategies usually advocated may be counterproductive in a
service context. Bring in a new management team? Better make sure you can do so
without wounding the confidence of frontline employees. Reduce costs? You
could, but you risk undermining morale, which will impair product delivery and
disappoint customers. Establish tight control over day-to-day operations?
Easier said than done when your key frontline employees are remote from
management.
To make matters worse, service company turnarounds are far more likely than
manufacturing turnarounds to become caught in a vicious cycle of deteriorating
performance. Faced with poor results, managers cut costs, slashing headcount
and trimming service. This damages the product and disheartens frontline
employees. Poor morale translates into poor service. Customers lose confidence
and defect to competitors, and the bottom line suffers.
MAINTAINING CUSTOMER LOYALTY
Sometimes companies forget that, over time, their existing
customers become more knowledgeable about competitors' offerings. Thus, buyers
need to be continually resold on the company and the products and services it
offers. One lawn care company experienced a loss of customers to its
competitors due to what appeared to be lower competitor prices. However, when
they compared their pricing structure with the competition, they discovered
that their price was actually comparable. Their competitors had unbundled the
various components of the lawn care service, pricing some components
separately, thereby giving the appearance of a lower price. Consequently, this
lawn care company went back not only to its lost customers, but also to all its
existing customers with a new pricing structure that gave all customers more
choice as to the service package and pricing level that would best fit their
needs.
Companies that want to maintain customer loyalty for the long haul
need to effectively gather relevant customer information through their sales
and service force, or through outside customer data gathering firms. Customer
information is vital in figuring out what products and services your current
customers value, and how you subsequently need to update or evolve your product
or service's positioning and packaging. This information can give you a
significant edge over your competitors. For example, that same lawn company
surveyed a subset of its customers and discovered various customer profiles. Some
customers wanted to interact with and learn from the lawn service person, while
others just wanted the work done without seeing the service person at all.
Armed with this and other learning from its customer data-gathering, the
company trained their sales and service personnel to position and package their
company's offerings to any current customer situation. As a result, they
improved their customer retention rate.
SUMMARY
Improving your company's customer service is a two-pronged
approach. Externally, a company needs to decide which customers it needs to
initially and subsequently focus on. The business needs to examine what it is
doing to generate new customers and what it needs to do to maintain, or
effectively prune, existing customers.
Internally, a company needs to figure out what's working and what
needs improvement with respect to its key internal supports. Committed
leadership is required to keep efforts going despite inevitable pain and
adversity, especially in a highly competitive business. Initial efforts need to
be targeted, starting small and building momentum. Employees and suppliers need
to be involved in analyses and actions in order to generate uniform commitment
and ensure that improvements stick. Employee competence and confidence needs to
be built to sustain your company's advantage over the long haul.
Performing all these external and internal efforts proactively and
intelligently will generate and ensure long-term success for your business.
with best
compliments
Dr Wilfred
Monteiro
No comments:
Post a Comment